求求，别毁经典！从新版《新龙门客栈》说起！
<!----><style type="text/css">html{font-size:375%}</style><link href="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/static/publish/css/style.css?v=1605251010499" rel="stylesheet" position="1" data-qf-origin="/static/publish/css/style.css?v=1605251010499"><!-- 付费贴--> <div class="preview_article "> <!----> <p>前段时间，已经结束的开年大剧《狂飙》掀起一股热潮。精彩的剧情和启强哥的精彩演绎，让大家意犹未尽，在现在的朋友圈和抖音，还衍生出无数和狂飙以及启强哥相关的内容。可见此剧影响力之大。</p><p class="">但今天，我们不说《狂飙》，也不说启强哥，来说说《新龙门客栈》。</p><p class="empty_paragraph"> </p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210124403front2_0_3837_Ft5AriHTdhzcpHOgumbNkxQLIxUK.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="720" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210124403front2_0_3837_Ft5AriHTdhzcpHOgumbNkxQLIxUK.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>对于《新龙门客栈》，可能大家看得最多、也觉得最经典的是1992年上映，由徐克担任编剧并监制，李惠民执导，梁家辉、林青霞、张曼玉、甄子丹、刘洵、吴启华等联袂主演的版本。</p><p class="empty_paragraph"> </p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210125036front2_0_3837_FhyHJcxgjJu0C75_8HySpVNXh9It.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1000" height="626" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210125036front2_0_3837_FhyHJcxgjJu0C75_8HySpVNXh9It.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>确实，作为一个武侠迷来说，92版的《新龙门客栈》在选角、造型、动作、剧情等各方面，都达到了顶峰，是大众心目中的武侠经典。尤其几个主演的精湛演技，真的令人叹为观止，至今仍旧让人无数次的刷。</p><p class="empty_paragraph"> </p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210125551front2_0_3837_FlsLYcHxN3aL2JxJNPbzC15Nll7U.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="676" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210125551front2_0_3837_FlsLYcHxN3aL2JxJNPbzC15Nll7U.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p> </p><p>而在徐克版《新龙门客栈》之前，其实还有个1976版的《龙门客栈》，由著名大导演胡金铨执导，但可能大多数人没看过。</p><p class="empty_paragraph"> </p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210125556front2_0_3837_Fqken3oWrEkcONFJr-DUa7gBR16K.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="608" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210125556front2_0_3837_Fqken3oWrEkcONFJr-DUa7gBR16K.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>而在1996年，还曾有过一部电视剧版本的《新龙门客栈》，由马景涛、陈红、夏文汐、郭晋安、关礼杰、李立群等主演。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210125823front2_0_3837_Fs6u7foaxA53XW8fEHT_gBCz2VrN.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="640" height="1080" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210125823front2_0_3837_Fs6u7foaxA53XW8fEHT_gBCz2VrN.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>从海报的造型上来看，其实也还算不错，有武侠剧的风骨。几个主演也都是实力派。虽然没有看过，但据相关报道，此剧在当时也是收获了大量好评的，</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210125954front2_0_3837_FhFRf2o5XnZjR28nDeNe_9Dd2tOm.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="600" height="800" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210125954front2_0_3837_FhFRf2o5XnZjR28nDeNe_9Dd2tOm.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p class="empty_paragraph"> </p><p class="">对于经典的作品，许多人都想翻拍，但无一例外，翻拍出来的都不尽人意，甚至是毁经典。比如什么《神雕侠侣》、《天龙八部》以及《射雕英雄传》等，好几部翻拍的都让人忍不住吐槽。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210130244front2_0_3837_Fo01Mh3XQ3mEi3WmJ14hYygLSa3q.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="800" height="600" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210130244front2_0_3837_Fo01Mh3XQ3mEi3WmJ14hYygLSa3q.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>而对于《新龙门客栈》这个IP，许多人也想尝试。其中，朱少杰导演在2017年就曾拍了《新龙门客栈》，但角色和角色造型一出，就引起不少的骂声。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210130321front2_0_3837_Fq8A5MbF5Vus0z-U0GbAGezoCvpf.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="810" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210130321front2_0_3837_Fq8A5MbF5Vus0z-U0GbAGezoCvpf.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>在选角上，导演启用的是当时正红的小生马可来饰演周淮安、沈梦辰饰演邱莫言、保剑锋饰演曹少钦，金镶玉则由戚薇饰演。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210131016front2_0_3837_FhFWvgnisLR4XZDHvLOclGsN--46.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="1516" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210131016front2_0_3837_FhFWvgnisLR4XZDHvLOclGsN--46.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p> </p><p>在选角上，我觉得已经失败。马可除了在《花千骨》中饰演“杀阡陌”一角被大家熟知，但现在究竟还有什么剧，我是真的不知道。再说周淮安一个具有正义感的锦衣卫，侠的气势与生俱来，马可没有。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210131144front2_0_3837_FvLKdJifY-bRtSSLT1_Fl3Z9qYv7.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="1508" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210131144front2_0_3837_FvLKdJifY-bRtSSLT1_Fl3Z9qYv7.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p> </p><p>沈梦辰作为一个主持人，前来饰演女侠邱莫言，外貌和气质都差林青霞和陈红太远，演技就更不用说了。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210131152front2_0_3837_Ft4OeiqQiPkcH3kA9R30a5z0y1JN.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="1520" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210131152front2_0_3837_Ft4OeiqQiPkcH3kA9R30a5z0y1JN.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>至于保剑锋，我是看《十八岁的天空》知道他的，演技还是有，饰演曹少钦我觉得没什么大问题。</p><p class="qf_image big noneditable" contenteditable="false"><img src="https://pic.app.jxapp.cn/forum/20230210131256front2_0_3837_FoMEx37wNNj2aJsbGxyw0jU274rX.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" alt="" width="1080" height="1558" data-qf-origin="forum/20230210131256front2_0_3837_FoMEx37wNNj2aJsbGxyw0jU274rX.jpg?watermark/3/image/aHR0cHM6Ly9waWMuYXBwLmp4YXBwLmNuL2FkbWluX0ZwcVJueWlqd1kxWDMxRkhXRVlldFJ6YXNSMUoucG5n/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/dx/10/dy/65/text/QOeLrOiHquetieW-hQ==/fontsize/400/dissolve/100/gravity/SouthEast/fill/I2ZmZmZmZg==/font/5b6u6L2v6ZuF6buR/dx/10/dy/35" /></p><p>而戚薇来饰演金镶玉，还有那么一点味道。但在造型上我觉得整体都有些过于华丽，和当时的环境真的不相符。</p><p>所以说，幸好此剧没有上映，不然真的是毁经典。在此，也希望各位导演在准备翻拍经典剧目时多一些思考，不要再让翻拍骂声一片了，拜托！！！</p> <!----></div> 翻拍经典炒别人的剩饭，靠这种捷径成功的几率也不高。 现在电视电影，服道化都是华丽，尤其是服装，看着就不舒服，我现在看武侠剧，都是看老剧，新剧不看，看不下去{:7_196:} 近几年翻拍的没几部成功的 翻拍与抄袭有何区别 看过《新龙门客栈》！ 谢谢分享 以前喜欢看。 翻牌的基本不看。 现在拍的剧已经失去了原著的魂，没有经典好看。
页:
[1]
2